The+Lion,+the+Witch,+and+the+Wardrobe

DIRECTIONS: Each student in the group is responsible for inventing one discussion question. This discussion question must be posted on the Monday of each week, ensuring time for discussion of each question. Each member of the group, including the person who invented the question, MUST respond to the discussion AT LEAST twice EACH week. Your participation in these online discussions, along with the amount of effort and reflection put into your responses, will account for a portion of your Literature Circle final grade. Each time you post a discussion question or a response,you MUST skip a space from what was written above, and you MUST begin your writing with your last name and first initial so I can mark your participation. It would also be helpful if you choose a specific colour and stick to that colour each week to identify yourself with also.

Week 4 Discussion Question: oharaD - Do you think that the witch well let edmund go, or make him be her server for the rest of his life ?

altertonC - no i do not think the witch will let edmund go she will turn him to stone or make him into her slave for the rest of his life altertonC - If the witch lets edmund go he will have to promise to bring someone else to be her slave.

GrattanN- i think that she will let him go eventually and if she doesnt then he will find his own way out..or someone will save him ./. or she might even DIE!!! oharaD - I agreee, you never know she might die , and she might not ! i hope she doesnt turn him into stone, i know what he did was bad , and mean but he doesnt diserve that. grattann-do you think that the which DIES .. i think she does.. if you have already reade the whole book you already know who dies .. does the which????????? oharaD- hahahaha nicole, i think that she does die , because thats kinda what happends.

KingR-she very well could kill Edmund and go after the others her self, she would not keep him as her servent because she needs to kill them to stay queen.

Week 3 Discussion Question: GrattanN- is peter goin to stay mad at edmund forever OharaD- Noo, i dont think Peter well hate Edmund forever , because they're brothers and you do sometimes get your little fights , and also your big ones , but in the end it always ends up good. And plus, if i would put myself in peters position , i could relate it this situation , because yaah , you lied to your siblings about something that you experienced , and espacilly when it was one of the younger ones who saw you , and knew you went there.

altertonC = no i think he is going to stay mad at him for awhile but not forever

KingR-Peter has a good reason to stay mad at Edmund for lieing to his little sister about not being in Narna but every one lies and people forgive.

grattann- i wouldnt stay mad forever but i still would be mad for a while because if i was peter i would of not lied to my lil sister in the first place that was rouid gettin her hopes up for nothing and you were really there and you just lied about it so you could be cool..... that i dont think is veryt nice./. oharaD- i totally agree with all of this, why would he do such a thing to his little sister , it wouldnt have been bad if he did it to someone maybe the same age as hhim , but to do it to such a little child , that has big hopes for in the world thats just low and rude ! , like why would you wanna build up a little girls hops and then jjust tare them down like what peter did to lucy, i deffently would NOT do that to me little brother and sister.

GrattanN-i think it was very disrespectiful.if i was lucy i would not be very happy. i agree with dominique it is very low and rude. and building up a little girls hopes up and then put them down and lie about it.. i dono who would do that..:(

KingR- I think peter should stay mad at edmund for awhile but brothers will be brothers and they will forgive each other. Week 2 Discussion Question:** OharaD - Why is it so long in narnia, but when you get back into the real world its only been a few minutes ? **

GrattanN- i think it's because narnia is a make-belife world and when you there it feels like you've been gone for ever just like if you went to bed and woke up and your like holy i've been gone for ever and really you have only been gone for like 10 minutes... **

OharaD - i agree with you nicole, thats what we dicussed in class , and i think thats what it is , because when your dreaming its like am imagination , and thats pretty much what the book is about a lot of imagonations.

grattann- yea i think only things like this can happen in a dream or if ur day dreaming ,and the book is pretty much just made up, but some times you actully think it is real..

family? **
 * Week 1 Discussion** **Question: KingR - How would it be like moving from one place to another with a new

altertonc i think it would b eweird to move to a differnt place with another family.

OharaD - i think it would be weird and it would really suck. Starting your life over pretty much, moving away from all your friends having to say good bye to everyone, thats really hard let alone your moving with people you dont even know that are pracitally strangers, and then having to go to school in the morning and having to meet all new people its really hard for people! I cant really relate to this because i havn't been with anyone else other then my parents / family, and also because i have been going to the same school that i was first inrolled with , that meaning i never really left in the middle of the year , or i havn't been in any of different school other then elemenatary middle school and high school.

** KingR-Moving to a new home would be hard because you would need to make friends all over agian, ** ** but moving with a new family would be harder because you don't know as well as your old family they may have different family rules like: curfue time, bed times, eating habbits e.c.t **

altertonC-to mave with a different family you would have to get use to them and there rules OHaraD  - Yeah i agree with KingR it would be really hard moving with a family and getting use to their rules. it would also be really awkward to talk to them. I think that moving away from your home that you had for a while and moving with all n ew people would be really hard, and i dont think i could do it. It would be really hard to move and start over with your life, and its even harder saying good bye to all your friends that you have been friends with pretty much your whole life

GrattanN - i agree it would be very hard moving from one place when you are so use to being around one family then movin to another place with peopl u dont know.